GNU bug report logs - #28084
lilypond, fontforge are not reproducible

Previous Next

To add a comment to this bug, you must first unarchive it, by sending
a message to control AT debbugs.gnu.org, with unarchive 28084 in the body.
You can then email your comments to 28084 AT debbugs.gnu.org in the normal way.

Toggle the display of automated, internal messages from the tracker.

Message #5 received at submit <at> debbugs.gnu.org (full text, mbox):

From: Danny Milosavljevic <dannym <at> scratchpost.org>
To: <bug-guix <at> gnu.org>
Subject: lilypond, fontforge are not reproducible
Date: Mon, 14 Aug 2017 05:24:07 +0200

+++ /gnu/store/5isa0knfahy345j3zw7yg9vzc073rfg4-lilypond-2.19.63-check/share/lilypond/2.19.63/fonts/svg/emmentaler-11.svg       1970-01-01 01:00:01.000000000 +0100
@@ -5,7 +5,7 @@
 -->
 <svg xmlns="http://www.w3.org/2000/svg" xmlns:xlink="http://www.w3.org/1999/xlink" version="1.1">
 <metadata>
-Created by FontForge 20160404 at Sun Aug 13 21:37:49 2017
+Created by FontForge 20160404 at Sun Aug 13 21:01:36 2017
  By Nix build user

And some actual strokes are different in the svg (for example the ones for glyph custodes.hufnagel.u0).

Binary files *.otf are different.
Binary files *.woff are different.

Message #8 received at 28084 <at> debbugs.gnu.org (full text, mbox):

From: zimoun <zimon.toutoune <at> gmail.com>
To: Danny Milosavljevic <dannym <at> scratchpost.org>
Cc: 28084 <at> debbugs.gnu.org
Subject: Re: bug#28084: lilypond, fontforge are not reproducible
Date: Tue, 22 Dec 2020 16:27:21 +0100

Hi,

The package lilypond is still not reproducible with Guix af34f75.

On Mon, 14 Aug 2017 at 05:24, Danny Milosavljevic <dannym <at> scratchpost.org> wrote:
> +++ /gnu/store/5isa0knfahy345j3zw7yg9vzc073rfg4-lilypond-2.19.63-check/share/lilypond/2.19.63/fonts/svg/emmentaler-11.svg       1970-01-01 01:00:01.000000000 +0100
> @@ -5,7 +5,7 @@
>  -->
>  <svg xmlns="http://www.w3.org/2000/svg" xmlns:xlink="http://www.w3.org/1999/xlink" version="1.1">
>  <metadata>
> -Created by FontForge 20160404 at Sun Aug 13 21:37:49 2017
> +Created by FontForge 20160404 at Sun Aug 13 21:01:36 2017
>   By Nix build user
>
> And some actual strokes are different in the svg (for example the ones for glyph custodes.hufnagel.u0).
>
> Binary files *.otf are different.
> Binary files *.woff are different.

--8<---------------cut here---------------start------------->8---
$ diff -r --no-dereference /gnu/store/93zlv6ylzc7v4b3gjg0smkbmgn34para-lilypond-2.20.0{,-check}
Les fichiers binaires /gnu/store/93zlv6ylzc7v4b3gjg0smkbmgn34para-lilypond-2.20.0/share/info/lilypond/36/lily-255a9d43.png et /gnu/store/93zlv6ylzc7v4b3gjg0smkbmgn34para-lilypond-2.20.0-check/share/info/lilypond/36/lily-255a9d43.png sont différents
Les fichiers binaires /gnu/store/93zlv6ylzc7v4b3gjg0smkbmgn34para-lilypond-2.20.0/share/info/lilypond/50/lily-6fe36958.png et /gnu/store/93zlv6ylzc7v4b3gjg0smkbmgn34para-lilypond-2.20.0-check/share/info/lilypond/50/lily-6fe36958.png sont différents
Les fichiers binaires /gnu/store/93zlv6ylzc7v4b3gjg0smkbmgn34para-lilypond-2.20.0/share/info/lilypond/70/lily-6b0704f6.png et /gnu/store/93zlv6ylzc7v4b3gjg0smkbmgn34para-lilypond-2.20.0-check/share/info/lilypond/70/lily-6b0704f6.png sont différents
Les fichiers binaires /gnu/store/93zlv6ylzc7v4b3gjg0smkbmgn34para-lilypond-2.20.0/share/lilypond/2.20.0/fonts/otf/emmentaler-11.otf et /gnu/store/93zlv6ylzc7v4b3gjg0smkbmgn34para-lilypond-2.20.0-check/share/lilypond/2.20.0/fonts/otf/emmentaler-11.otf sont différents
Les fichiers binaires /gnu/store/93zlv6ylzc7v4b3gjg0smkbmgn34para-lilypond-2.20.0/share/lilypond/2.20.0/fonts/otf/emmentaler-13.otf et /gnu/store/93zlv6ylzc7v4b3gjg0smkbmgn34para-lilypond-2.20.0-check/share/lilypond/2.20.0/fonts/otf/emmentaler-13.otf sont différents
Les fichiers binaires /gnu/store/93zlv6ylzc7v4b3gjg0smkbmgn34para-lilypond-2.20.0/share/lilypond/2.20.0/fonts/otf/emmentaler-14.otf et /gnu/store/93zlv6ylzc7v4b3gjg0smkbmgn34para-lilypond-2.20.0-check/share/lilypond/2.20.0/fonts/otf/emmentaler-14.otf sont différents
Les fichiers binaires /gnu/store/93zlv6ylzc7v4b3gjg0smkbmgn34para-lilypond-2.20.0/share/lilypond/2.20.0/fonts/otf/emmentaler-18.otf et /gnu/store/93zlv6ylzc7v4b3gjg0smkbmgn34para-lilypond-2.20.0-check/share/lilypond/2.20.0/fonts/otf/emmentaler-18.otf sont différents
Les fichiers binaires /gnu/store/93zlv6ylzc7v4b3gjg0smkbmgn34para-lilypond-2.20.0/share/lilypond/2.20.0/fonts/otf/emmentaler-23.otf et /gnu/store/93zlv6ylzc7v4b3gjg0smkbmgn34para-lilypond-2.20.0-check/share/lilypond/2.20.0/fonts/otf/emmentaler-23.otf sont différents
Les fichiers binaires /gnu/store/93zlv6ylzc7v4b3gjg0smkbmgn34para-lilypond-2.20.0/share/lilypond/2.20.0/fonts/otf/emmentaler-26.otf et /gnu/store/93zlv6ylzc7v4b3gjg0smkbmgn34para-lilypond-2.20.0-check/share/lilypond/2.20.0/fonts/otf/emmentaler-26.otf sont différents
Les fichiers binaires /gnu/store/93zlv6ylzc7v4b3gjg0smkbmgn34para-lilypond-2.20.0/share/lilypond/2.20.0/fonts/otf/emmentaler-brace.otf et /gnu/store/93zlv6ylzc7v4b3gjg0smkbmgn34para-lilypond-2.20.0-check/share/lilypond/2.20.0/fonts/otf/emmentaler-brace.otf sont différents
diff -r --no-dereference /gnu/store/93zlv6ylzc7v4b3gjg0smkbmgn34para-lilypond-2.20.0/share/lilypond/2.20.0/fonts/svg/emmentaler-11.svg /gnu/store/93zlv6ylzc7v4b3gjg0smkbmgn34para-lilypond-2.20.0-check/share/lilypond/2.20.0/fonts/svg/emmentaler-11.svg
817,818c817,818
< d="M0 205c85 51 197 129 197 226c0 21 -4 42 -11 61c-78 -82 -186 -151 -186 -267v-20zM266 656c0 -44 -16 -81 -39 -114c16 -35 25 -73 25 -111c0 -179 -252 -252 -252 -431h-25v500h25v-70c91 49 210 126 210 226c0 19 -6 38 -15 55v6c0 18 15 31 31 31
< c35 0 40 -61 40 -92z" />
---
> d="M227 542c23 33 39 70 39 114c0 31 -5 92 -40 92c-16 0 -31 -13 -31 -31v-6c9 -17 15 -36 15 -55c0 -100 -119 -177 -210 -226v-225c85 51 197 129 197 226c0 21 -4 42 -11 61c15 16 29 32 41 50c16 -35 25 -73 25 -111c0 -179 -252 -252 -252 -431h-25v500h25v-275
> c0 116 108 185 186 267c-5 13 -11 25 -19 37c0 2 -1 4 -1 6c0 18 16 31 32 31c14 0 23 -10 29 -24z" />

[...]
--8<---------------cut here---------------end--------------->8---


All the best,
simon

Message #11 received at 28084 <at> debbugs.gnu.org (full text, mbox):

From: zimoun <zimon.toutoune <at> gmail.com>
To: Danny Milosavljevic <dannym <at> scratchpost.org>
Cc: 28084 <at> debbugs.gnu.org
Subject: Re: bug#28084: lilypond, fontforge are not reproducible
Date: Tue, 12 Apr 2022 11:48:30 +0200

Hi,

Using 3670480, it is still the case, see below.

On mar., 22 déc. 2020 at 16:27, zimoun <zimon.toutoune <at> gmail.com> wrote:
> The package lilypond is still not reproducible with Guix af34f75.
>
> On Mon, 14 Aug 2017 at 05:24, Danny Milosavljevic <dannym <at> scratchpost.org> wrote:
>> +++ /gnu/store/5isa0knfahy345j3zw7yg9vzc073rfg4-lilypond-2.19.63-check/share/lilypond/2.19.63/fonts/svg/emmentaler-11.svg       1970-01-01 01:00:01.000000000 +0100
>> @@ -5,7 +5,7 @@
>>  -->
>>  <svg xmlns="http://www.w3.org/2000/svg" xmlns:xlink="http://www.w3.org/1999/xlink" version="1.1">
>>  <metadata>
>> -Created by FontForge 20160404 at Sun Aug 13 21:37:49 2017
>> +Created by FontForge 20160404 at Sun Aug 13 21:01:36 2017
>>   By Nix build user
>>
>> And some actual strokes are different in the svg (for example the ones for glyph custodes.hufnagel.u0).
>>
>> Binary files *.otf are different.
>> Binary files *.woff are different.

How do we tackle this old bug?


Cheers,
simon



--8<---------------cut here---------------start------------->8---
simon <at> pfiuh07$ diff -r --no-dereference /gnu/store/fi4v4dsksfaqrvg61chnfzyis3rzx59q-lilypond-2.20.0{,-check}
Binary files /gnu/store/fi4v4dsksfaqrvg61chnfzyis3rzx59q-lilypond-2.20.0/share/info/lilypond/09/lily-2be182be.png and /gnu/store/fi4v4dsksfaqrvg61chnfzyis3rzx59q-lilypond-2.20.0-check/share/info/lilypond/09/lily-2be182be.png differ
Binary files /gnu/store/fi4v4dsksfaqrvg61chnfzyis3rzx59q-lilypond-2.20.0/share/info/lilypond/0b/lily-1c5fca01.png and /gnu/store/fi4v4dsksfaqrvg61chnfzyis3rzx59q-lilypond-2.20.0-check/share/info/lilypond/0b/lily-1c5fca01.png differ
Binary files /gnu/store/fi4v4dsksfaqrvg61chnfzyis3rzx59q-lilypond-2.20.0/share/info/lilypond/41/lily-2c8b3dd2.png and /gnu/store/fi4v4dsksfaqrvg61chnfzyis3rzx59q-lilypond-2.20.0-check/share/info/lilypond/41/lily-2c8b3dd2.png differ
Binary files /gnu/store/fi4v4dsksfaqrvg61chnfzyis3rzx59q-lilypond-2.20.0/share/info/lilypond/50/lily-6fe36958.png and /gnu/store/fi4v4dsksfaqrvg61chnfzyis3rzx59q-lilypond-2.20.0-check/share/info/lilypond/50/lily-6fe36958.png differ
Binary files /gnu/store/fi4v4dsksfaqrvg61chnfzyis3rzx59q-lilypond-2.20.0/share/info/lilypond/56/lily-f9c182c3.png and /gnu/store/fi4v4dsksfaqrvg61chnfzyis3rzx59q-lilypond-2.20.0-check/share/info/lilypond/56/lily-f9c182c3.png differ
Binary files /gnu/store/fi4v4dsksfaqrvg61chnfzyis3rzx59q-lilypond-2.20.0/share/info/lilypond/70/lily-6b0704f6.png and /gnu/store/fi4v4dsksfaqrvg61chnfzyis3rzx59q-lilypond-2.20.0-check/share/info/lilypond/70/lily-6b0704f6.png differ
Binary files /gnu/store/fi4v4dsksfaqrvg61chnfzyis3rzx59q-lilypond-2.20.0/share/info/lilypond/d6/lily-1eaf4a7b.png and /gnu/store/fi4v4dsksfaqrvg61chnfzyis3rzx59q-lilypond-2.20.0-check/share/info/lilypond/d6/lily-1eaf4a7b.png differ
Binary files /gnu/store/fi4v4dsksfaqrvg61chnfzyis3rzx59q-lilypond-2.20.0/share/info/lilypond/fd/lily-1981c3c7.png and /gnu/store/fi4v4dsksfaqrvg61chnfzyis3rzx59q-lilypond-2.20.0-check/share/info/lilypond/fd/lily-1981c3c7.png differ
Binary files /gnu/store/fi4v4dsksfaqrvg61chnfzyis3rzx59q-lilypond-2.20.0/share/lilypond/2.20.0/fonts/otf/emmentaler-11.otf and /gnu/store/fi4v4dsksfaqrvg61chnfzyis3rzx59q-lilypond-2.20.0-check/share/lilypond/2.20.0/fonts/otf/emmentaler-11.otf differ
Binary files /gnu/store/fi4v4dsksfaqrvg61chnfzyis3rzx59q-lilypond-2.20.0/share/lilypond/2.20.0/fonts/otf/emmentaler-14.otf and /gnu/store/fi4v4dsksfaqrvg61chnfzyis3rzx59q-lilypond-2.20.0-check/share/lilypond/2.20.0/fonts/otf/emmentaler-14.otf differ
Binary files /gnu/store/fi4v4dsksfaqrvg61chnfzyis3rzx59q-lilypond-2.20.0/share/lilypond/2.20.0/fonts/otf/emmentaler-16.otf and /gnu/store/fi4v4dsksfaqrvg61chnfzyis3rzx59q-lilypond-2.20.0-check/share/lilypond/2.20.0/fonts/otf/emmentaler-16.otf differ
Binary files /gnu/store/fi4v4dsksfaqrvg61chnfzyis3rzx59q-lilypond-2.20.0/share/lilypond/2.20.0/fonts/otf/emmentaler-18.otf and /gnu/store/fi4v4dsksfaqrvg61chnfzyis3rzx59q-lilypond-2.20.0-check/share/lilypond/2.20.0/fonts/otf/emmentaler-18.otf differ
Binary files /gnu/store/fi4v4dsksfaqrvg61chnfzyis3rzx59q-lilypond-2.20.0/share/lilypond/2.20.0/fonts/otf/emmentaler-20.otf and /gnu/store/fi4v4dsksfaqrvg61chnfzyis3rzx59q-lilypond-2.20.0-check/share/lilypond/2.20.0/fonts/otf/emmentaler-20.otf differ
Binary files /gnu/store/fi4v4dsksfaqrvg61chnfzyis3rzx59q-lilypond-2.20.0/share/lilypond/2.20.0/fonts/otf/emmentaler-23.otf and /gnu/store/fi4v4dsksfaqrvg61chnfzyis3rzx59q-lilypond-2.20.0-check/share/lilypond/2.20.0/fonts/otf/emmentaler-23.otf differ
Binary files /gnu/store/fi4v4dsksfaqrvg61chnfzyis3rzx59q-lilypond-2.20.0/share/lilypond/2.20.0/fonts/otf/emmentaler-26.otf and /gnu/store/fi4v4dsksfaqrvg61chnfzyis3rzx59q-lilypond-2.20.0-check/share/lilypond/2.20.0/fonts/otf/emmentaler-26.otf differ
Binary files /gnu/store/fi4v4dsksfaqrvg61chnfzyis3rzx59q-lilypond-2.20.0/share/lilypond/2.20.0/fonts/otf/emmentaler-brace.otf and /gnu/store/fi4v4dsksfaqrvg61chnfzyis3rzx59q-lilypond-2.20.0-check/share/lilypond/2.20.0/fonts/otf/emmentaler-brace.otf differ
diff -r --no-dereference /gnu/store/fi4v4dsksfaqrvg61chnfzyis3rzx59q-lilypond-2.20.0/share/lilypond/2.20.0/fonts/svg/emmentaler-11.svg /gnu/store/fi4v4dsksfaqrvg61chnfzyis3rzx59q-lilypond-2.20.0-check/share/lilypond/2.20.0/fonts/svg/emmentaler-11.svg
1449c1449
< d="M182 125c16 0 18 -95 18 -125s-2 -125 -18 -125h-164c-16 0 -18 95 -18 125s2 125 18 125h164z" />
---
> d="M18 -125c-16 0 -18 95 -18 125s2 125 18 125h164c16 0 18 -95 18 -125s-2 -125 -18 -125h-164z" />
Binary files /gnu/store/fi4v4dsksfaqrvg61chnfzyis3rzx59q-lilypond-2.20.0/share/lilypond/2.20.0/fonts/svg/emmentaler-11.woff and /gnu/store/fi4v4dsksfaqrvg61chnfzyis3rzx59q-lilypond-2.20.0-check/share/lilypond/2.20.0/fonts/svg/emmentaler-11.woff differ
diff -r --no-dereference /gnu/store/fi4v4dsksfaqrvg61chnfzyis3rzx59q-lilypond-2.20.0/share/lilypond/2.20.0/fonts/svg/emmentaler-14.svg /gnu/store/fi4v4dsksfaqrvg61chnfzyis3rzx59q-lilypond-2.20.0-check/share/lilypond/2.20.0/fonts/svg/emmentaler-14.svg
580c580
< d="M0 93c0 9 7 16 16 16h292c9 0 17 -7 17 -16v-56c0 -84 -76 -146 -163 -146s-162 62 -162 146v56z" />
---
> d="M33 44v-7c0 -53 67 -64 129 -64s130 11 130 64v7h-259zM0 93c0 9 7 16 16 16h292c9 0 17 -7 17 -16v-56c0 -84 -76 -146 -163 -146s-162 62 -162 146v56z" />
996c996
< d="M158 11l123 175c9 13 47 67 59 58c13 -9 -25 -65 -33 -76l-175 -250c-7 -10 -53 -73 -61 -56l-70 146c-2 4 0 12 5 24c13 29 44 73 66 94c11 11 21 18 24 12z" />
---
> d="M96 138l62 -127l123 175c9 13 47 67 59 58c13 -9 -25 -65 -33 -76l-175 -250c-8 -11 -55 -69 -61 -56l-70 146c-2 4 0 12 5 24c6 14 17 32 29 50c8 11 55 69 61 56z" />
1016c1016
< d="M60 -139c9 0 10 112 10 139v-365c0 -5 -5 -10 -10 -10s-9 5 -9 10v226h9zM70 0c0 5 -5 10 -10 10s-9 -5 -9 -10v-139h-41c-9 0 -10 111 -10 139c0 27 1 139 10 139h50c9 0 10 -112 10 -139z" />
---
> d="M60 139c9 0 10 -112 10 -139v-365c0 -5 -5 -10 -10 -10s-9 5 -9 10v226h-41c-9 0 -10 112 -10 139c0 28 1 139 10 139h50z" />
Binary files /gnu/store/fi4v4dsksfaqrvg61chnfzyis3rzx59q-lilypond-2.20.0/share/lilypond/2.20.0/fonts/svg/emmentaler-14.woff and /gnu/store/fi4v4dsksfaqrvg61chnfzyis3rzx59q-lilypond-2.20.0-check/share/lilypond/2.20.0/fonts/svg/emmentaler-14.woff differ
diff -r --no-dereference /gnu/store/fi4v4dsksfaqrvg61chnfzyis3rzx59q-lilypond-2.20.0/share/lilypond/2.20.0/fonts/svg/emmentaler-16.svg /gnu/store/fi4v4dsksfaqrvg61chnfzyis3rzx59q-lilypond-2.20.0-check/share/lilypond/2.20.0/fonts/svg/emmentaler-16.svg
574c574
< d="M0 94c0 9 8 16 17 16h292c9 0 16 -7 16 -16v-56c0 -84 -75 -148 -162 -148s-163 64 -163 148v56z" />
---
> d="M33 44v-6c0 -53 68 -66 130 -66s129 13 129 66v6h-259zM0 94c0 9 8 16 17 16h292c9 0 16 -7 16 -16v-56c0 -84 -75 -148 -162 -148s-163 64 -163 148v56z" />
Binary files /gnu/store/fi4v4dsksfaqrvg61chnfzyis3rzx59q-lilypond-2.20.0/share/lilypond/2.20.0/fonts/svg/emmentaler-16.woff and /gnu/store/fi4v4dsksfaqrvg61chnfzyis3rzx59q-lilypond-2.20.0-check/share/lilypond/2.20.0/fonts/svg/emmentaler-16.woff differ
diff -r --no-dereference /gnu/store/fi4v4dsksfaqrvg61chnfzyis3rzx59q-lilypond-2.20.0/share/lilypond/2.20.0/fonts/svg/emmentaler-18.svg /gnu/store/fi4v4dsksfaqrvg61chnfzyis3rzx59q-lilypond-2.20.0-check/share/lilypond/2.20.0/fonts/svg/emmentaler-18.svg
818,819c818,819
< d="M0 205c88 50 204 128 204 227c0 22 -3 43 -8 64c-77 -87 -196 -155 -196 -276v-15zM267 863c0 -38 -12 -70 -30 -100c16 -38 24 -79 24 -120c0 -38 -12 -70 -30 -100c11 -36 17 -73 17 -111c0 -178 -248 -254 -248 -432h-18v750h18v-105c96 44 222 116 222 218
< c0 18 -10 34 -10 52c0 14 13 23 25 23c28 0 30 -50 30 -75zM0 425c94 45 217 118 217 218c0 26 -4 52 -13 77c-79 -88 -204 -156 -204 -280v-15z" />
---
> d="M0 205c88 50 204 128 204 227c0 22 -3 43 -8 64c-77 -87 -196 -155 -196 -276v-15zM237 763c18 30 30 62 30 100c0 25 -2 75 -30 75c-12 0 -25 -9 -25 -23c0 -18 10 -34 10 -52c0 -102 -126 -174 -222 -218v-220c94 45 217 118 217 218c0 26 -4 52 -13 77
> c12 14 24 28 33 43c16 -38 24 -79 24 -120c0 -38 -12 -70 -30 -100c11 -36 17 -73 17 -111c0 -178 -248 -254 -248 -432h-18v750h18v-310c0 124 125 192 204 280c-4 12 -16 26 -16 39c0 14 13 24 25 24s19 -9 24 -20z" />
993c993
< d="M94 136l63 -128l125 178c9 13 45 65 56 58c11 -8 -27 -62 -34 -73l-175 -250c-8 -11 -53 -67 -58 -57l-71 143c-2 3 1 12 7 24c7 14 17 31 29 48c8 11 53 67 58 57z" />
---
> d="M157 8l125 178c9 13 45 65 56 58c11 -8 -27 -62 -34 -73l-175 -250c-7 -10 -51 -71 -58 -57l-71 143c-2 3 1 12 7 24c13 28 44 71 65 92c11 11 20 18 22 13z" />
Binary files /gnu/store/fi4v4dsksfaqrvg61chnfzyis3rzx59q-lilypond-2.20.0/share/lilypond/2.20.0/fonts/svg/emmentaler-18.woff and /gnu/store/fi4v4dsksfaqrvg61chnfzyis3rzx59q-lilypond-2.20.0-check/share/lilypond/2.20.0/fonts/svg/emmentaler-18.woff differ
diff -r --no-dereference /gnu/store/fi4v4dsksfaqrvg61chnfzyis3rzx59q-lilypond-2.20.0/share/lilypond/2.20.0/fonts/svg/emmentaler-20.svg /gnu/store/fi4v4dsksfaqrvg61chnfzyis3rzx59q-lilypond-2.20.0-check/share/lilypond/2.20.0/fonts/svg/emmentaler-20.svg
819,821c819,821
< d="M217 788c-12 0 -23 -8 -23 -22c0 -15 9 -31 12 -44c-77 -87 -206 -149 -206 -271v-26v-200v-20c86 60 199 148 199 251c0 19 -2 37 -5 55c13 16 25 33 35 50c7 -35 12 -70 12 -105c0 -181 -241 -271 -241 -452v-4h-16v1000h16v-125c97 23 224 73 224 165
< c0 22 -7 43 -7 64c0 14 12 23 24 23c7 0 14 -4 19 -12c4 -25 7 -50 7 -75c0 -30 -9 -55 -23 -78c11 -36 17 -73 17 -110c0 -31 -8 -59 -22 -84c-4 12 -10 20 -22 20zM229 561c-3 13 -10 21 -22 21s-23 -9 -23 -23c0 -16 8 -33 10 -48c-76 -91 -194 -163 -194 -285v199
< c92 51 214 131 214 234c0 21 -3 42 -8 63c13 14 24 30 33 46c11 -35 17 -72 17 -109c0 -36 -10 -69 -27 -98zM0 650c95 38 219 104 219 202c0 23 -3 46 -9 68c-78 -77 -210 -127 -210 -244v-26z" />
---
> d="M-16 0v1000h16v-125c97 23 224 73 224 165c0 22 -7 43 -7 64c0 14 12 23 24 23c7 0 14 -4 19 -12c4 -25 7 -50 7 -75c0 -30 -9 -55 -23 -78c11 -36 17 -73 17 -110c0 -31 -8 -59 -22 -84c11 -35 17 -72 17 -109c0 -36 -10 -69 -27 -98c7 -35 12 -70 12 -105
> c0 -181 -241 -271 -241 -452v-4h-16zM0 204c86 60 199 149 199 252c0 19 -2 37 -5 55c-76 -91 -194 -163 -194 -286v-21zM0 425c92 51 214 131 214 234c0 21 -3 42 -8 63c-77 -87 -206 -150 -206 -272v-25zM0 650c95 38 219 104 219 202c0 23 -3 46 -9 68
> c-78 -77 -210 -128 -210 -245v-25z" />
1039c1039,1040
< d="M47 98c-15 0 -28 -11 -41 -12v-209v-4c33 59 94 117 94 167c0 24 -21 58 -53 58zM82 129c37 0 68 -33 68 -65c0 -53 -68 -115 -100 -179c-5 -10 -31 -24 -45 -24c-1 -5 -3 -11 -5 -11c-5 0 -6 19 -6 27v345c0 8 1 28 6 28s6 -20 6 -28v-127c22 21 50 34 76 34z" />
---
> d="M6 -123c0 -5 -8 -16 -1 -16c-1 -5 -3 -11 -5 -11c-5 0 -6 19 -6 27v345c0 8 1 28 6 28s6 -20 6 -28v-127c-3 -3 -9 -10 0 -9v-209zM47 98c-15 0 -28 -11 -41 -12v9c22 21 50 34 76 34c37 0 68 -33 68 -65c0 -53 -68 -115 -100 -179c-5 -10 -30 -24 -45 -24c1 3 1 8 1 12
> c33 59 94 117 94 167c0 24 -21 58 -53 58z" />
1459c1460
< d="M1250 -226v451h50v-451h-50zM1200 225v-451h-50v46h-1000v-46h-50v451h50v-45h1000v45h50zM0 -226v451h50v-451h-50zM150 -45h1000v90h-1000v-90z" />
---
> d="M1250 -226v451h50v-451h-50zM100 -226v451h50v-45h1000v45h50v-451h-50v46h-1000v-46h-50zM0 -226v451h50v-451h-50zM150 -45h1000v90h-1000v-90z" />
Binary files /gnu/store/fi4v4dsksfaqrvg61chnfzyis3rzx59q-lilypond-2.20.0/share/lilypond/2.20.0/fonts/svg/emmentaler-20.woff and /gnu/store/fi4v4dsksfaqrvg61chnfzyis3rzx59q-lilypond-2.20.0-check/share/lilypond/2.20.0/fonts/svg/emmentaler-20.woff differ
diff -r --no-dereference /gnu/store/fi4v4dsksfaqrvg61chnfzyis3rzx59q-lilypond-2.20.0/share/lilypond/2.20.0/fonts/svg/emmentaler-23.svg /gnu/store/fi4v4dsksfaqrvg61chnfzyis3rzx59q-lilypond-2.20.0-check/share/lilypond/2.20.0/fonts/svg/emmentaler-23.svg
990c990
< d="M156 6l170 242c9 12 46 64 55 58c9 -7 -29 -61 -36 -71l-219 -312c-7 -10 -49 -70 -55 -58l-71 142c-1 3 1 11 7 23c14 27 44 70 64 91c10 11 19 18 21 14z" />
---
> d="M92 135l64 -129l170 242c8 12 46 64 55 58c9 -7 -29 -61 -36 -71l-219 -312c-7 -11 -51 -66 -55 -58l-71 142c-1 3 1 11 7 23c7 13 18 30 30 47c7 11 51 66 55 58z" />
1451c1451
< d="M1232 -227v454h47v-454h-47zM1186 227v-454h-47v46h-1000v-46h-46v454h46v-46h1000v46h47zM0 -227v454h46v-454h-46zM139 -45h1000v90h-1000v-90z" />
---
> d="M1232 -227v454h47v-454h-47zM93 -227v454h46v-46h1000v46h47v-454h-47v46h-1000v-46h-46zM0 -227v454h46v-454h-46zM139 -45h1000v90h-1000v-90z" />
Binary files /gnu/store/fi4v4dsksfaqrvg61chnfzyis3rzx59q-lilypond-2.20.0/share/lilypond/2.20.0/fonts/svg/emmentaler-23.woff and /gnu/store/fi4v4dsksfaqrvg61chnfzyis3rzx59q-lilypond-2.20.0-check/share/lilypond/2.20.0/fonts/svg/emmentaler-23.woff differ
diff -r --no-dereference /gnu/store/fi4v4dsksfaqrvg61chnfzyis3rzx59q-lilypond-2.20.0/share/lilypond/2.20.0/fonts/svg/emmentaler-26.svg /gnu/store/fi4v4dsksfaqrvg61chnfzyis3rzx59q-lilypond-2.20.0-check/share/lilypond/2.20.0/fonts/svg/emmentaler-26.svg
1032,1033c1032
< d="M5 93c-3 -2 -8 -7 0 -6v-210c0 -6 -8 -15 -1 -15c-1 -5 -2 -12 -4 -12c-5 0 -5 20 -5 27v345c0 7 0 28 5 28s5 -21 5 -28v-129zM46 99c-15 0 -28 -11 -41 -12v6c22 21 51 35 77 35c36 0 68 -33 68 -64c0 -53 -68 -115 -100 -178c-5 -10 -32 -23 -46 -24c0 3 1 6 1 9
< c32 60 95 118 95 169c0 24 -22 59 -54 59z" />
---
> d="M46 99c-15 0 -28 -11 -41 -12v-210v-6c32 60 95 117 95 168c0 24 -22 60 -54 60zM82 128c36 0 68 -33 68 -64c0 -53 -68 -115 -100 -178c-5 -10 -32 -23 -46 -24c-1 -5 -2 -12 -4 -12c-5 0 -5 20 -5 27v345c0 7 0 28 5 28s5 -21 5 -28v-129c22 21 51 35 77 35z" />
Binary files /gnu/store/fi4v4dsksfaqrvg61chnfzyis3rzx59q-lilypond-2.20.0/share/lilypond/2.20.0/fonts/svg/emmentaler-26.woff and /gnu/store/fi4v4dsksfaqrvg61chnfzyis3rzx59q-lilypond-2.20.0-check/share/lilypond/2.20.0/fonts/svg/emmentaler-26.woff differ
diff -r --no-dereference /gnu/store/fi4v4dsksfaqrvg61chnfzyis3rzx59q-lilypond-2.20.0/share/lilypond/2.20.0/fonts/svg/emmentaler-brace.svg /gnu/store/fi4v4dsksfaqrvg61chnfzyis3rzx59q-lilypond-2.20.0-check/share/lilypond/2.20.0/fonts/svg/emmentaler-brace.svg
131,132c131,132
< d="M-49 -346c0 -46 12 -85 54 -104c5 -2 7 -6 7 -10c0 -6 -5 -12 -12 -12c-2 0 -3 0 -5 1c-67 30 -96 101 -96 177c0 63 22 126 22 184c0 46 -12 84 -54 103c-3 1 -4 4 -4 7l11 -7c5 2 9 4 13 7c58 -34 84 -101 84 -172c0 -59 -20 -119 -20 -174zM-49 346
< c0 -55 20 -115 20 -174c0 -71 -26 -138 -84 -172c-4 3 -8 5 -13 7l-11 -7c0 3 1 6 4 7c42 19 54 57 54 103c0 58 -22 121 -22 184c0 76 29 147 96 177c2 1 3 1 5 1c7 0 12 -6 12 -12c0 -4 -2 -8 -7 -10c-42 -19 -54 -58 -54 -104z" />
---
> d="M-29 -172c0 -60 -20 -119 -20 -174c0 -46 12 -85 54 -104c5 -2 7 -6 7 -10c0 -6 -5 -12 -12 -12c-2 0 -3 0 -5 1c-67 30 -96 101 -96 177c0 63 22 126 22 184c0 46 -12 84 -54 103c-3 1 -4 4 -4 7s1 6 4 7c42 19 54 57 54 103c0 58 -22 121 -22 184c0 76 29 147 96 177
> c2 1 3 1 5 1c7 0 12 -6 12 -12c0 -4 -2 -8 -7 -10c-42 -19 -54 -58 -54 -104c0 -55 20 -115 20 -174c0 -71 -26 -138 -84 -172c58 -34 84 -101 84 -172z" />
167,168c167,168
< d="M-28 -193c0 -74 -27 -147 -27 -216c0 -52 14 -96 60 -120c5 -2 7 -6 7 -10c0 -6 -5 -13 -12 -13c-2 0 -3 1 -5 2c-72 37 -102 115 -102 198c0 77 29 155 29 226c0 51 -14 95 -60 119c-3 1 -4 4 -4 7s1 6 4 7c46 24 60 68 60 119c0 71 -29 149 -29 226
< c0 83 30 161 102 198c2 1 3 2 5 2c7 0 12 -7 12 -13c0 -4 -2 -8 -7 -10c-46 -24 -60 -68 -60 -120c0 -69 27 -142 27 -216c0 -79 -27 -153 -90 -193c63 -40 90 -114 90 -193z" />
---
> d="M-55 -409c0 -52 14 -96 60 -120c5 -2 7 -6 7 -10c0 -6 -5 -13 -12 -13c-2 0 -3 1 -5 2c-72 37 -102 115 -102 198c0 77 29 155 29 226c0 51 -14 95 -60 119c-3 1 -4 4 -4 7l11 -7c4 2 9 4 13 7c63 -40 90 -114 90 -193c0 -74 -27 -147 -27 -216zM-55 409
> c0 -69 27 -142 27 -216c0 -79 -27 -153 -90 -193c-4 3 -9 5 -13 7l-11 -7c0 3 1 6 4 7c46 24 60 68 60 119c0 71 -29 149 -29 226c0 83 30 161 102 198c2 1 3 2 5 2c7 0 12 -7 12 -13c0 -4 -2 -8 -7 -10c-46 -24 -60 -68 -60 -120z" />
173,174c173,174
< d="M-56 -420c0 -53 15 -97 62 -122c5 -2 6 -6 6 -10c0 -6 -5 -13 -12 -13c-2 0 -4 0 -6 1c-73 38 -102 118 -102 202c0 80 31 159 31 233c0 52 -15 98 -62 122c-3 1 -4 4 -4 7l11 -7c4 2 9 4 13 7c64 -41 91 -116 91 -196c0 -76 -28 -153 -28 -224zM-56 420
< c0 -71 28 -148 28 -224c0 -80 -27 -155 -91 -196c-4 3 -9 5 -13 7l-11 -7c0 3 1 6 4 7c47 24 62 70 62 122c0 74 -31 153 -31 233c0 84 29 164 102 202c2 1 4 1 6 1c7 0 12 -7 12 -13c0 -4 -1 -8 -6 -10c-47 -25 -62 -69 -62 -122z" />
---
> d="M-143 0c0 3 1 6 4 7c47 24 62 70 62 122c0 74 -31 153 -31 233c0 84 29 164 102 202c2 1 4 1 6 1c7 0 12 -7 12 -13c0 -4 -1 -8 -6 -10c-47 -25 -62 -69 -62 -122c0 -71 28 -148 28 -224c0 -80 -27 -155 -91 -196c84 -53 84 -268 84 -268c-9 -50 -21 -104 -21 -152
> c0 -53 15 -97 62 -122c5 -2 6 -6 6 -10c0 -6 -5 -13 -12 -13c-2 0 -4 0 -6 1c-73 38 -102 118 -102 202c0 80 31 159 31 233c0 52 -15 98 -62 122c-3 1 -4 4 -4 7z" />
188,189c188,189
< d="M-58 -447c0 -55 15 -102 64 -129c5 -2 6 -6 6 -10c0 -6 -5 -13 -12 -13c-2 0 -4 0 -6 1c-75 41 -105 123 -105 211c0 86 34 171 34 251c0 55 -15 102 -64 129c-3 1 -5 4 -5 7l12 -7c4 2 9 4 13 7c67 -43 94 -123 94 -206c0 -82 -31 -164 -31 -241zM-58 447
< c0 -77 31 -159 31 -241c0 -83 -27 -163 -94 -206c-4 3 -9 5 -13 7l-12 -7c0 3 2 6 5 7c49 27 64 74 64 129c0 80 -34 165 -34 251c0 88 30 170 105 211c2 1 4 1 6 1c7 0 12 -7 12 -13c0 -4 -1 -8 -6 -10c-49 -27 -64 -74 -64 -129z" />
---
> d="M-27 -206c0 -83 -31 -164 -31 -241c0 -55 15 -102 64 -129c5 -2 6 -6 6 -10c0 -6 -5 -13 -12 -13c-2 0 -4 0 -6 1c-75 41 -105 123 -105 211c0 86 34 171 34 251c0 55 -15 102 -64 129c-3 1 -5 4 -5 7s2 6 5 7c49 27 64 74 64 129c0 80 -34 165 -34 251
> c0 88 30 170 105 211c2 1 4 1 6 1c7 0 12 -7 12 -13c0 -4 -1 -8 -6 -10c-49 -27 -64 -74 -64 -129c0 -77 31 -159 31 -241c0 -83 -27 -163 -94 -206c67 -43 94 -123 94 -206z" />
314,315c314,315
< d="M-22 -290c0 -136 -56 -270 -56 -398c0 -78 20 -148 86 -196c14 -10 -2 -32 -16 -22c-94 68 -128 178 -128 294c0 140 60 278 60 410c0 78 -22 148 -86 194c-2 2 -4 6 -4 8s2 6 4 8c64 46 86 116 86 194c0 132 -60 270 -60 410c0 116 34 226 128 294c14 10 30 -12 16 -22
< c-66 -48 -86 -118 -86 -196c0 -128 56 -262 56 -398c0 -114 -34 -222 -120 -290c86 -68 120 -176 120 -290z" />
---
> d="M-22 -290c0 -136 -56 -270 -56 -398c0 -78 20 -148 86 -196c14 -10 -2 -32 -16 -22c-94 68 -128 178 -128 294c0 140 60 278 60 410c0 78 -22 148 -86 194c-2 2 -4 6 -4 8l14 -8c4 2 6 6 10 8c86 -68 120 -176 120 -290zM-22 290c0 -114 -34 -222 -120 -290
> c-4 2 -6 6 -10 8l-14 -8c0 2 2 6 4 8c64 46 86 116 86 194c0 132 -60 270 -60 410c0 116 34 226 128 294c14 10 30 -12 16 -22c-66 -48 -86 -118 -86 -196c0 -128 56 -262 56 -398z" />
Binary files /gnu/store/fi4v4dsksfaqrvg61chnfzyis3rzx59q-lilypond-2.20.0/share/lilypond/2.20.0/fonts/svg/emmentaler-brace.woff and /gnu/store/fi4v4dsksfaqrvg61chnfzyis3rzx59q-lilypond-2.20.0-check/share/lilypond/2.20.0/fonts/svg/emmentaler-brace.woff differ
--8<---------------cut here---------------end--------------->8---

Message #14 received at 28084 <at> debbugs.gnu.org (full text, mbox):

From: Nicolas Graves <ngraves <at> ngraves.fr>
To: 28084 <at> debbugs.gnu.org
Cc: zimoun.toutoune <at> gmail.com
Subject: lilypond, fontforge are not reproducible
Date: Fri, 10 May 2024 14:17:37 +0200

`guix challenge lilypond` now seems to pass, and "Created by FontForge
..." strings in emmentaler-*.svg files indeed indicate 1st Jan 1970.

I guess we can close the issue @Zimoun?

-- 
Best regards,
Nicolas Graves

Message #19 received at 28084-done <at> debbugs.gnu.org (full text, mbox):

From: Simon Tournier <zimon.toutoune <at> gmail.com>
To: Nicolas Graves <ngraves <at> ngraves.fr>
Cc: 28084-done <at> debbugs.gnu.org, zimoun.toutoune <at> gmail.com
Subject: Re: bug#28084: lilypond, fontforge are not reproducible
Date: Wed, 22 May 2024 17:19:30 +0200

Hi,

On ven., 10 mai 2024 at 14:17, Nicolas Graves <ngraves <at> ngraves.fr> wrote:

> `guix challenge lilypond` now seems to pass, and "Created by FontForge
> ..." strings in emmentaler-*.svg files indeed indicate 1st Jan 1970.
>
> I guess we can close the issue @Zimoun?

Indeed, using Guix 6ba29e0, I do not see any reproducibility issue.  So
closing!

Thanks for the follow-up.

Cheers,
simon

Previous Next

GNU bug tracking system
Copyright (C) 1999 Darren O. Benham, 1997,2003 nCipher Corporation Ltd, 1994-97 Ian Jackson.